Yes/No Recs: Books I Read in September

Yes/No Recommendations: Books I Read in September 2026

October 2, 2026

•

Prose & Cons

Below are all the books I finished reading (or listening to) in September 2026, along with a yes/no whether I recommend them for you to read, too!

The God of the Woods by Liz Moore

God of the Woods by Liz Moore — 👍YES!

Starting off strong with a resounding YES for this one! God of the Woods is set in the mid-1970s at a summer camp where Barbara Van Laar, daughter of the wealthy camp owners, goes missing in much the same way her older brother did years before. What seems like a simple mystery of a teenager lost in the woods gets much darker and more twisted as the story progresses, and I simply couldn't put it down.

There are a lot of characters to keep track of, and Moore changes perspectives chapter-to-chapter jumping between them, but I promise it's 100% worth sticking it out. I absolutely LOVED the ending of this book, which was unexpected and a million times better and more satisfying than anything I could have predicted. I rated this a 4.5/5 on StoryGraph but now I'm second guessing my stinginess of a 5/5 on this one.

The Gate of the Feral Gods by Matt Dinniman

The Gate of the Feral Gods by Matt Dinniman — 👍 Yes

I'm all-in on the Dungeon Crawler Carl series at this point, and by book 4 we really start to see more character depth after all the setup that happens in books 1-3. (Not to mention wading through the confusion that is the iron tangle in book 3!) I'm not sure if I'd enjoy these books quite as much if I were reading them (I could be wrong though), but the audiobooks are absolutely outstanding. In theory, there's no reason I should love this series as much as I do—it's not anything I'd normally read, listen to, or gravitate toward in TV or movies. But I've absolutely fallen in love with so many of Matt Dinniman's characters (a testament to his writing AND to Jeff Hays' voice acting), so I can't stop coming back for more.

(Technically as of this writing on Oct. 2, I just finished book 5 and am starting book 6. I'm legit worried what I'm going to do when I finish 8 and have to wait for 9...)

The Unknown by Riley Sager

The Unknown by Riley Sager — 👍 (a slightly less enthusiastic) Yes

This book follows aspiring actress Marin when she is offered the breakout role of a lifetime alongside legendary actress Violet Wright. But in order to make it to filming, she first has to join the movie's iconic and eccentric director, Ronan Peters, and the rest of the core cast on New Avalon, a desolate island where the events being portrayed in the horror film actually took place in 1926, so that they can experience firsthand what the women inspiring their roles went though. Somehow this book wasn't exactly what I was expecting based on the synopses I'd read of it. I think I expected a little more supernatural horror and historical lore, but it ultimately felt like more of a modern thriller (which isn't a bad thing). Where were a few plot points that were eye-rolling to me (I won't mention them because spoilers), but ultimately still a good read and I'll definitely pick up more Riley Sager books in the future because I did like his writing style overall.

Carrie by Stephen King

Carrie by Stephen King — 👎No (please don't hurt me!)

Seriously—I feel like I should be ducking and covering for rotten tomatoes or shoes being thrown at me over this one—but I really hated this book. A lot. I won't summarize the plot because I think most people have likely either read the book or watched the movie, but let me preface it by saying: (1) this is the first Stephen King book I've ever read, and (2) I've never seen the movie, though I had a vague awareness of it (that it involved a girl who was bullied, a bucket of pig blood, and telekinesis, but that's about it).

It may have been my mistake to choose this particular title for my first Stephen King read. I know Stephen King is absolutely an iconic writer, but I was intimidated to start with one of his more lengthy books till I got a feel for his style, and I also thought that starting with his first published novel made sense. Turns out... my bad.

The thing that I hated most about this book is that, to me, it felt like a short story that could have been told in 100 pages or less instead of 300. All of the news clippings interjected throughout just felt like padding. Turns out, had I read up on this book a bit more, I'd have found out that it had been a short story. One that Stephen King had thrown in the garbage, but his wife fished out and encouraged him to finish it. He did, in fact, add all the news clippings and excerpts to get it to novel-length for publishing. So I guess it's a feature not a bug, as they say?

I also hated that it felt like there wasn't a huge amount of character development. It just felt like we got a tiny sneak-peek into the world, and then just watched it all burn. Again, I think that's intentional—but just not for me.

I've questioned whether to even share my feelings on this book because I feel like it makes me look like a "bad reader" if I don't get Stephen King. But maybe this just wasn't a great title to start with? I'm thinking I'll revisit another one of his books in the future.

books